16 November 2005

Demise of CD Singles

The singles format has been dead for years. It was evident as early as the eighties when vinyl singles were dominant and CD singles were just making in-roads.

By the early nineties, CD singles had become the dominant format but they were never as prevalent as the 7" vinyl singles were during the heydays of records in the sixties and seventies.

Then came Napster, Sound Galaxy and other means of electronic distribution. The day of the CD single was clearly limited and would probably see limited production in future, much like how small batches of records are manufactured.

The recent announcement by A Different Drum and Metropolis Records to cease issuing CD singles is a reflection of hard economic realities. The returns from the amount of sales generated often does not justify the initial capital outlay and the creation of the singles themselves.


Todd Durrant from A Different Drum noted that:

"But as the label has trudged onward through the last 10 years, it has become more and more apparent that singles are nothing but a cash drain. Maybe if I'd looked around and seen that other similar labels had already given up singles, and that even the major labels were releasing fewer singles, I would have caught on. But I enjoyed the fact that ADD was different-- we were keeping the maxi-single alive!

CD singles cost nearly as much to manufacture as the album, when it comes to material costs. When we're also paying for remixes, artwork design, etc. it starts to cost a lot of money. I'd justify the expense by clumping it in with the cost of the album production. By considering the single an appendage to album, I could just say that the extra $2500 spent on a single was just part of the album budget. But hey, that made for some very large album budgets for such a small scene. Realistically, so few people were buying the singles anymore, and so few DJ's were actually using them in the clubs, that it has finally hit me like a brick in the head that I have to give them up."

It is unfortunate that more and more niche players and specialists are bowing out. In the end, it is going to be major labels with their CD singles of sorry acts like Madonna, U2 and others. Tragic. Oh well. This is the end of an era.

'Foreign coin on a telephone box
A question mark on a calendar
An empty seat on the alpha line
A sorting code, an account number"
'Playgirl' Ladytron

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

Yes. Hastened no doubt by legal services like iTunes Music Store as well...

Chuang Shyue Chou said...

Can you check if the iTunes store carries music from these Metropolis Records and A Different Drum bands?

God Module
Lights of Euphoria
Cosmicity
Keithevez

The fact is that the labels would often have six to nine remixes on each single. The costs of commissioning them is probably high for small labels to moderate-sized with a pressing run of 1000-2000 copies.

I would be surprised if they are on iTunes, including the remixes of the singles.

Chuang Shyue Chou said...

Yes, legal and illegal services do contribute but vinyl 7" singles were already on the demise even before the advent of the CD in the early eighties. Heheh.

Of course, I am only bemoaning the fact that A Different Drum and Metropolis Records are going to stop issuing singles.

If Maverick Records or Island Records stop, I can't care less of course. Heheheh.

Merv Kwok said...

have never bought a single in my life seriously. could never afford one considering from which part of the world i come from hehe.

in msia, a single goes for rm30. a cd for rm40. so yea.

Chuang Shyue Chou said...

CD singles here are expensive too. They cost between S$7.95 to S$18.00 with the average costing about S$14.00.

I guess it is not very different from Malaysia then?

Singles in the UK cost between 2 to 4 pounds (circa 1996) and US$4.00 (circa 1990).

They are pretty much luxuries.

Alicia said...

hmm u can get RM5 one in m'sia :P

Chuang Shyue Chou said...

Hahahaah.

CD singles for RM5! That's great. Are these stores still prevalent in Malaysia?

The last time I visited Holiday Plaza in Johor was in 1996. Awesome place! I love it. Somehow, I have only been to Malaysia twice in over thirty years. The second time was nine years ago and the first time was about thirty years ago.

There is a secondhand store at Marina Square that sells CD singles for S$3.90.

Alicia said...

hehe u can c alot of those RM5 cds at petaling street :P.. i dono about johor..

m'sia .. nothin muc.. but there r lots of good food if u noe how to find them..

Merv Kwok said...

eh guys.. um... RIAA. haha

Chuang Shyue Chou said...

Heheh. Merv, I buy originals. Hence, I have listed my favourite store online:

http://www.adifferentdrum.com

I recommend that store and I have been purchasing from them for a decade. Since 1995.

Alicia, how's KL? I have heard it is the most dynamic city in South East Asia, growing by leaps and bounds with over 90 malls in KL alone. I haven't seen the place for over three decades really. Petaling Street you say? Hmmm.. Interesting!

Alicia said...

KL arhh.. kinda ok lor.. nothin muc to visit xcept for shopping malls.. there's a new one called the times square dat is located at the golden triangle.. a very huge one.. besides that we've even got the mid valley megamall.. i prefer to go to midvalley...

if u were to go to midvalley.. i'd recommend chilis for foods.. it's a nice place..

b'sides that u can even go for a visit at KLCC.. there's a new aquarium thing nearby..